Historical and political context
Mental health has always been political, even when that history has remained outside mainstream accounts of identity and political behavior. The book examines how definitions of mental illness have been bound up with social norms and political power, including instances in which people were regarded as mentally unwell because their actions challenged prevailing authority. It then turns to the contemporary emergence of mental health identity.
The research
Empirical chapters
Empirical chapter 1
Mental health as an emerging political identity
The first empirical chapter outlines my mental health identity batteries, which examine closeness with the ingroup, importance of identification to self, strength of identification within the ingroup, and alienation. Using the 2022 Cooperative Election Study (CES), I find that people who have experienced mental illness feel close to others who have experienced mental illness. Further, they are likely to self-categorize themselves as having had a mental illness, share a sense of group consciousness with others who have had mental illness, and recognize the need to work together to change laws that are unfair to people with mental illness.
I also find an emerging mental health political identity that is most pronounced among younger (Gen Z) and more liberal Americans. There is also a strong correlation between mental health categorization, identification, and alienation, and the expressed desire for increased healthcare, education, and welfare spending. Interestingly, I find that on average those who self-categorize and score highly on the mental health identity and/or alienation scales are just as likely to participate politically and use (social) media as those who do not self-categorize and have low scores on the mental health identity and/or alienation scales.
One of the principal contributions of this project is showing that mental health identity seems to be distinct in terms of social and political consequences from (physical) disability identity and serious chronic physical illness identity. These findings have far-reaching consequences for mental health advocacy and the role mental health identity will play in the political sphere—especially as Gen Z matures as a cohort.
Related publication in Political Behavior ↗
Empirical chapter 2
Mental health, disability, and health-related identities
The second empirical chapter analyzes a mental health identity battery with expanded disability categories that was in the 2024 American National Election Study (ANES) pilot. Overall, I find that this slightly different mental health battery supports the findings in the first empirical chapter. Further, I find that many Americans categorize themselves as having a disability or chronic condition and also consider it as relatively important to their identity. Strength of identification varies by condition.
I focus on the health-related/disability condition category and the mental health condition category primarily due to power constraints. I find that health categorization and identification vary by gender, race, ideology, party ID, and generational cohort. I examine significant predictors for the health and mental health measures. Finally, I use the health and mental health measures to predict the impact of several dependent variables, including political exhaustion, election stress, and the importance of healthcare as a voting issue.
Empirical chapter 3
Candidate disclosures and political representation
The third empirical chapter analyzes two survey experiments fielded through Lucid, a survey research company. The first was conducted at the start of 2022 (N = 1,425) and the second was conducted March 2024. The first survey experiment investigates how voters react to political candidates who have a mental illness versus a candidate who is rude. Using fictional New York Times-style vignettes, I find that voters in the United States are much more likely to favor and vote for candidates with depression than for candidates who have heroin addiction or who are rude. These results are stronger for certain respondent attributes: gender, party ID, and history of mental illness. Democrats are significantly more likely to favor and vote for candidates with depression or heroin addiction than Republicans; women are more likely to favor decreasing social restrictiveness than men; and respondents with a history of mental illness are much more likely to favor and vote for candidates with depression than respondents without a history of mental illness.
The second survey experiment is a conceptual replication of the first but adds my mental health identity battery as a moderator. I find that with a true control condition and subtle treatments, there is not much of an electoral penalty for candidates with depression in terms of favorability or vote choice, but there is for candidates with schizophrenia.
In terms of general mental health categorization—have a mental health condition or not—those who have a mental health condition are much more likely to favor and vote for politicians with depression and schizophrenia. As for specific mental health conditions, respondents who said they have schizophrenia or depression are more likely to vote for candidates with depression or schizophrenia than respondents without diagnoses. Finally, the mental health identity measure is a strong moderator for the schizophrenia condition and the mental health alienation measure is a strong moderator for both experimental conditions.
Empirical chapter 4
Partisan and ideological differences in mental health
The fourth empirical chapter investigates the differences in mental health categorization, identification, and alienation among liberals (Democrats) and conservatives (Republicans). Previous research has found that liberals (Democrats) have worse reported mental health than conservatives (Republicans) (see Bernardi 2021b; Lukianoff 2024; Craig 2023; Lyons et al. 2025). I find that Republicans and conservatives do not consider depression and anxiety to be a mental health condition at the same rate as Democrats and liberals. This contrasts with all other mental health conditions, which are reported at about the same rates for liberals (Democrats) and conservatives (Republicans).
I also find that Republicans (conservatives) seek treatment at lower rates than Democrats (liberals). Since depression and anxiety are among the most prevalent mental health conditions, it is possible that Republicans (conservatives) seek treatment less often (or not at all) for symptomology normally classified as depression and/or anxiety because they do not consider it to be a mental illness. I also investigate personal responsibility ethos: they do not seek help when they think they can resolve the issues on their own (Lyons et al. 2025; Taber et al. 2015).
Empirical chapter 5
Mental health status threat and political mobilization
The fifth empirical chapter, titled “Weaponizing Public Health for Political Gain: A Mental Health Status Threat Survey Experiment,” examines how Americans respond to escalating levels of mental-health status threat, ranging from symbolic messages to coercive state action. Recent work has found that mental health is an emerging politicized social identity in the United States. However, little research investigates how individuals react when government actors signal that people with mental-health conditions require surveillance, regulation, or removal from public life.
To address this gap, I am developing a survey experiment using fictional news articles to examine responses to different types of threat, including stigmatizing messages, proposals for structured confinement and medication withdrawal, and federal restrictions on psychiatric medications. The study examines emotional reactions, policy attitudes, and political mobilization, asking whether these threats activate mental health identity. The survey design and data collection are in progress.